
Ornette Coleman alto saxophone
Don Cherry cornet
Charlie Haden double bass
Billy Higgins drums
All compositions by Ornette Coleman
Recorded May 22, 1959, at Radio Recorders, Hollywood, California
Engineered by Bones Howe
Produced by Nesuhi Ertegün
Cover photograph by William Claxton and cover design by Marvin Israel
Liner notes by Martin Williams
Released in November 1959 by Atlantic Records (1317 mono, SD 1317 stereo)
Billy Higgins strikes twice, and the floor of “Focus on Sanity” sprouts wings to meet the quartet in midair. Charlie Haden has just finished his bass solo when Ornette Coleman and Don Cherry snap back into the tune, and the band is in double time almost as soon as the horns get the melody between their teeth. Nearly fifty years later, Haden told Ethan Iverson how the four of them had never discussed that cue. Cherry helped sort the parts at his house, where everybody had time to get the hang of the changes of tempo Coleman had written into the arrangements. Otherwise, their synergy was left to fate.
Coleman came up playing rhythm and blues in Fort Worth, and he found his way into the record business as a composer hoping to sell a few tunes. In Los Angeles, bassist Red Mitchell sent him to Lester Koenig at Contemporary, who asked Coleman to play the pieces himself and heard enough to want him back with a band. Walter Norris played piano on Something Else!!!! The Music of Ornette Coleman in 1958, with Cherry and Higgins already alongside the young saxophonist. That fall, all four future members of the Atlantic quartet worked in Paul Bley’s quintet at the Hillcrest Club, where Bley got to play “When Will the Blues Leave?” with its composer. It would later turn up on Paul Bley with Gary Peacock, ECM’s third release. By the time the Hillcrest players convened as a quartet at Radio Recorders in May 1959, Coleman had made the pianoless Tomorrow Is the Question! with Shelly Manne on drums and Red Mitchell and Percy Heath dividing the bass duties.
“Lonely Woman” opens with the strum of Haden’s bass and the brisk stippling of Higgins’s cymbals. When the horns enter, they stretch the melody far across the beat. Coleman and Cherry leave a hairline opening between their pitches. When the former solos, he keeps turning toward the immediate past, and what sounded incidental the first time comes back bearing the whole weight of the line. Immediately, my mind goes to the twelve-minute version Cherry and Haden recorded with Dewey Redman and Ed Blackwell in Oslo in 1979, on ECM’s Old and New Dreams. Where the bass had set the original in motion, it now seems at liberty to tell us what it saw. Decades later in the same city, Arild Andersen took the tune entirely into his own hands for Landloper, extending the bridge under the influence of the singer Karin Krog and letting the melody lead into “Song for Che,” which Haden had played with Coleman in 1969. Andersen gives a singer’s sense of breath to the instrument that got the first word in 1959.
A few months after the Hollywood session, Coleman and Cherry had somebody else’s tune to get their mouths around. At the School of Jazz in Lenox, Massachusetts, they played Margo Guryan’s “Inn Tune” alongside Coleman’s own pieces in an ensemble led by John Lewis and Max Roach. Lewis had helped bring Coleman to the attention of Nesuhi Ertegün at Atlantic, and Martin Williams’s liner notes put Coleman in Lenox with Gunther Schuller at work editing the tapes. At the Five Spot on November 17, Haden was taking the cover off his bass when he caught sight of Wilbur Ware and Charles Mingus at the bar. Paul Chambers, who had played the opening figure on “So What” only months earlier, was there with Percy Heath, who had already recorded with Coleman. Haden took to playing with his eyes closed and, on a later night, opened them to find Leonard Bernstein on the bandstand with his ear to one of the f-holes. The booking had been for two weeks, and the quartet stayed for months. At a Town Hall concert that November, Whitney Balliett heard Coleman take a phrase in “Lonely Woman” down to the bottom of the alto, where the notes wavered with the obstinacy of a human voice. In 1962 Lewis made the tune the title track of a Modern Jazz Quartet album, and Milt Jackson’s vibraphone gave that lament a peculiar tenderness.
At hand, the horns stay so close on “Eventually” that when they separate, one can almost feel the teeth of a zipper opening at speed. Charlie Parker is still audible in the velocity with which Coleman comes out of the head, even as the lengths of his phrases grow gloriously uncountable. He gets a neigh out of the reed and bites into Higgins’s supple ride beat, while Cherry’s line is spindlier, with a point so fine he can puncture the time and leave it swinging. When I first encountered Bley’s 1999 recording from Lugano, I kept coming back to how hard Gary Peacock and Paul Motian swung under “When Will the Blues Leave?” Bley had room in his right hand for a snap that used to pass between two horns, and the trio could suspend him there for as long as the thought took. “Peace” takes that alertness down to the scale of a single breath. The slow groove opens out around Haden’s arco prayer, and what starts with care in Coleman’s solo suddenly comes out in little flutters, as though his lungs had been keeping a second account of everything his fingers let through.
On the second side, the outburst at the start of “Focus on Sanity” clears so abruptly that for a while Haden’s bass seems to occupy a space the rest of the quartet has had to evacuate. Coleman wanted to name the whole album for this tune, and I wonder how much of the joke was there in the turn from that initial racket to a single man thinking out loud. It was Ertegün who chose The Shape of Jazz to Come, a title that suits what happens when Higgins has the others back on their feet. Coleman keeps changing directions in double time, leaving a curl of the previous phrase in the air every time he bolts. Cherry eases off sufficiently to give his notes their full diameter, and Higgins gets a stretch of his own in which to reckon with what the acceleration has set loose. In July 1960, Cherry took the piece into the studio again with John Coltrane for The Avant-Garde, with Percy Heath and Ed Blackwell answering in the places Haden and Higgins had occupied. That December, Coleman reunited the band for Free Jazz, where Higgins and Blackwell played across the stereo field in separate quartets.
More than two decades on, Haden and Higgins brought the same quickness of attention to Rejoicing, recorded with Pat Metheny at the Power Station. “Tears Inside” and the title tune take the trio back to Coleman’s Contemporary sessions with Shelly Manne. Metheny finds a peculiar slipperiness in “Humpty Dumpty,” which comes from This Is Our Music. For that effort, my attention goes straight to the brushwork around Metheny’s acoustic guitar on the opener, Horace Silver’s “Lonely Woman.” There’s a quiet pleasure in finding Higgins on the other end of that exchange on the ECM duets Which Way Is East, taped in 2001 at the home of Charles Lloyd, whom Cherry had introduced to Higgins in Los Angeles. Higgins brought the guitar he used to take on the road and gave his own fingers the job of getting a melody into the air.
“Congeniality” has the most courteous title on the record, and Cherry takes advantage of its good manners to get away with some of his wildest storytelling. There’s a suspension in the head where the horns seem to pull chairs up to a table, and when Cherry has the floor he can make a passing remark that changes the subject of the entire visit. This gift for making a small utterance count again appears on ECM’s Dona Nostra, in the duet with pianist Bobo Stenson on Coleman’s “What Reason Could I Give.” A note from Cherry can travel the whole distance between them there, and Stenson’s answer gives us a way to hear where it has been. “Chronology” hits the ground running, and a growl can climb into a bright cornet note in the length of half a syllable. Coleman responds in cells so densely packed that any one of them could hatch its own argument. Bend a note far enough here and you can feel the hinge at the back of your own jaw. John Zorn and Tim Berne took “Chronology” into the studio where Metheny’s trio had made Rejoicing, and on Spy vs. Spy they put the tune through a little over a minute of hardcore abrasion. One can hear Coleman’s indulgence in making a phrase outrun its own measure in that version, and something of the same appetite in the way Berne’s later ECM quartet Snakeoil could stretch a phrase.
When Lewis and Schuller asked Guryan to write words for “Lonely Woman,” she followed the contours of the composed melody in the outer sections. Coleman improvised the bridge, so she had to work from the recording they gave her, choosing pieces of his improvisation and making a line where a singer could find sustenance. Linda Sharrock took it into AM4’s …and she answered in 1989, and Elina Duni sings it with guitarist Rob Luft on Reaching for the Moon. It’s a peculiar intimacy to find in somebody’s phrasing a place for the lungs of a person they could never have imagined. I think of Bernstein bending to the wood of Haden’s bass and of the minute stirrup of bone inside his ear, taking the motion of another body into its own, until the last note exhales into his soul.









