Carla Bley
4×4

Lew Soloff trumpet
Wolfgang Puschnig alto saxophone, flute
Andy Sheppard tenor saxophone
Gary Valente trombone
Carla Bley piano
Larry Goldings organ
Steve Swallow bass
Victor Lewis drums
Recorded July 1999 at Rainbow Studio, Oslo
Engineer: Jon Marius Aareskjold
Mixed and mastered at Grog Kill Studio, Willow, New York
Engineer: Tom Mark
General co-ordination: Ilene Mark
Produced by Carla Bley and Steve Swallow
Release date: September 25, 2000

While touring across Europe with a newly fashioned octet in July of 1999, Carla Bley and friends stepped into Oslo’s Rainbow Studio to record 4×4. The set opens its eyes as if waking from a bygone dream in “Blues In 12 Bars / Blues In 12 Other Bars.” These two mirrors are faced toward each other, so that an infinity reflection ensues. Running between them, as far as the ear can hear, are her familiar horn section of Lew Soloff (trumpet), Wolfgang Puschnig (alto saxophone and flute), Andy Sheppard (tenor saxophone), and Gary Valente (trombone), while Bley herself from the piano helms a crew of Larry Goldings (the sole newcomer, on organ), Steve Swallow (bass), and Victor Lewis (drums). The welcome mat thus laid, we step into as pleasant an introduction to the band’s rapport as we might imagine. Likeminded contrasts abound in “Baseball,” thereby throwing the first pitch of a tight game between the two quartets, whose crosstalk gives rise to a leaping catch from Valente. Sheppard’s whispering tenor in “Útviklingssang” closes out the season with what is by far the most superior arrangement of this beloved tune. “Sidewinders In Paradise” revives the playfulness of earlier Bley and shuffles rainforest chatter with urban chic, setting up a menagerie of in-house solos.

But the reigning queen is “Les Trois Lagons (d’apres Henri Matisse).” Originally commissioned by the Grenoble Jazz Festival and inspired by Jazz, a series of cut-outs by Henri Matisse, it was first performed by her trio with Swallow and Sheppard in 1996. At nearly 16 minutes, it’s a viable piece of history. As cigarette smoke and laughter hang over the heads of upwardly mobile socialites and starving artists alike, it morphs into an aural cubism.

So much of Bley’s output by now is worth listening to that the word “essential” loses more meaning with each subsequent release. Don’t hesitate to dive into this one and trust its air supply to bring you safely back to the surface.

The Carla Bley Big Band
Goes To Church

Lew Soloff, Guy Barker, Claude Deppa, Steve Waterman trumpets
Gary Valente, Pete Beachill, Chris Dean trombones
Richard Henry bass trombone
Roger Jannotta soprano and alto saxophones, flute
Wolfgang Puschnig alto saxophone
Andy Sheppard, Jerry Underwood tenor saxophones
Julian Argüelles baritone saxophone
Karen Mantler organ, harmonica
Carla Bley piano
Steve Swallow bass
Dennis Mackrel drums
Recorded live at Chiesa San Francesco Al Prato, Umbria Jazz, Perugia, Italy, July 19-21, 1996
Engineer: Mirco Bezzi
Live sound: Bill Strode
Assistants: Vittorio Albani and Sandro Giudici (Gianni Grassilli Sound Services)
Mixed at Grog Kill Studio, Willow, New York
Engineer: Tom Mark
Mastered by Tom Mark at The Make Believe Ballroom
General co-ordination: Ilene Mark
Produced by Carla Bley and Steve Swallow
Release date: November 1, 1996

Recorded live in July of 1996 at Italy’s renowned Umbria Jazz Festival, Goes To Church pits the Carla Bley Big Band against its own reputation, only to exceed it. The title in this case is a reference to the venue in which it was performed and recorded—the Church of San Francesco al Prato—rather than to any spiritual agenda (Bley grew up in the church but left it behind at 15 when she fled home and landed in New York City to make history). This doesn’t, however, prevent any listener fortunate enough to sit in these pews from having a metaphysical experience.

“Setting Calvin’s Waltz” is a prime example of Bley’s mastery in a program consisting of nothing but. Commissioned by the Berlin Jazz Festival, the 24-minute extravaganza feels like walking through an apartment complex of episodic blocks, allowing glimpses into the everyday lives therein. A rocking introduction floats us on bluesy waters while Karen Mantler’s organ brings a gospel feel to the undertow. The tenor of Andy Sheppard awakens the surrounding horns from their catatonic state. From here, trumpeter Lew Soloff and trombonist Gary Valente take over in a more theatrical mode. Mantler gets the quietest of spotlights for her forlorn harmonica solo before opening the floor to Wolfgang Puschnig’s potent altoism. A likeminded reverence imbues the triptych that follows. Opening with Carl Ruggles’s “Exaltation” and flowing into Bley’s “Religious Experience” and “Major,” it lays a groundwork of horns as an excuse to riff on Handel’s “Hallelujah” chorus. Puschnig’s alto barrels through as Dennis Mackrel’s drumming crushes the devil’s adversaries on its way to upbeat salvation.

The set’s deepest enlightenment is embodied in the appropriately titled “One Way,” a hymn of burnished brass and patient world building that leaves one tenderly fulfilled. It shares oxygen with “Permanent Wave,” another unusual sequence of development, and feeds the “Beads” between them. The latter tune, commissioned by the Carnegie Hall Jazz Band, is smooth at the center yet frayed at the edges. Sheppard’s tenor is once again the star, paving the way for Soloff and Mackrel to strut their stuff. The benediction of “Who Will Rescue You?” leaps for joy as Puschnig goes for closing gold.

A personal favorite among Bley’s live big band excursions.

Carla Bley
Big Band Theory

Alex Balanescu violin
Lew Soloff, Guy Barker, Claude Deppa, Steve Waterman trumpets
Gary Valente, Richard Edwards, Annie Whitehead trombones
Ashley Slater bass trombone
Roger Jannotta soprano saxophone, flute
Wolfgang Puschnig alto saxophone, flute
Andy Sheppard tenor and soprano saxophones
Pete Hurt tenor saxophone
Julian Argüelles baritone saxophone
Carla Bley piano
Karen Mantler organ
Steve Swallow bass
Dennis Mackrel drums
Recorded July 2/3, 1993 at Angel Studios, London
Engineer: Gary Thomas
Mixed at Grog Kill Studio, Willow, New York
Engineer: Tom Mark
Mastered by Greg Calbi at Sterling Sound
General co-ordination: Ilene Mark
Produced by Carla Bley and Steve Swallow
Release date: October 1, 1993

In the footsteps of her last (very) big band effort—which, despite its competence isn’t my favorite—Carla Bley returns with a masterstroke of the genre. It’s all here: catchy titles, musicians who share a profound cohesion, and tunes to unpack with joy. “On the Stage in Cages” sets the tone by jumping into the woodwork and rearranging every whorl with confidence. Bley’s band, holding firm at 18 members, swings with renewed purpose, as if waking up from the slumber of hiatus in a sublime return to form. This is followed by one of the highest peaks in the Bley mountain range: “Birds of Paradise.” Commissioned by the 1992 Glasgow Jazz Festival, it foregrounds violinist Alex(ander) Balanescu, whose folk-tinged glow warms this body from the inside before morphing into a moody and dramatic pile of brass. Bley’s characteristic attention to detail throughout this 20-minute journey is as varied as any life that could contain it.

Bley taps the inkwell of her muse, Charles Mingus, in a personal arrangement of “Goodbye Pork Pie Hat,” which despite its straight-laced veneer sports a dark monologue from bass trombonist Ashley Slater, alluring trumpeting by Lew Soloff, and a gentle swing beneath it all. Bley comes up from this dedicatory nod with her own “Fresh Impression” firmly in hand. This blast of sunshine yields a robust solo from Andy Sheppard on tenor, as if to emphasize the flow of memory he and the others ride to the present moment. It and everything that precedes is indeed fresh music that imparts its invitation to all listeners. This is Bley’s house, and the catering has been perfectly laid out before we even walk in.

The Very Big Carla Bley Band

Lew Soloff, Guy Barker, Claude Deppa, Steven Bernstein trumpets
Gary Valente, Richard Edwards, Fayyaz Virji trombones
Ashley Slater bass trombone
Roger Jannotta oboe, flute, clarinet, soprano saxophone
Wolfgang Puschnig alto saxophone, flute
Andy Sheppard tenor and soprano saxophones
Pete Hurt tenor saxophone, clarinet
Pablo Calogero baritone saxophone
Steve Swallow bass
Carla Bley piano
Karen Mantler organ
Victor Lewis drums
Don Alias percussion
Recorded October 29/30, 1990 at Bauer Studios, Ludwigsburg, Germany
Engineer: Carlos Albrecht
Mixed at Grog Kill Studio, Willow, New York
Engineer: Tom Mark
Mastered by Greg Calbi at Sterling Sound, New York
General co-ordination: Michael Mantler
Produced by Carla Bley and Steve Swallow
Release date: April 1, 1991

If the explosion of sentiment that embraced Carla Bley in the mid-1980s led to a soul-defining period, then let this 18-piece extravaganza be the backdraft that pulled her into a wider angle. Despite boasting trumpeter Lew Soloff, trombonist Gary Valente, and saxophonists Wolfgang Puschnig and Andy Sheppard as frontline soloists, it’s not the most groundbreaking of sessions, but a respectable enough jewel in the Bley crown.

Right off the bat, “United States” shows us just how much Bley’s sense of humor has grown. From the splashing cymbals of Victor Lewis to the anthemic inflections of bassist Steve Swallow, there’s much to admire in this ensemble’s knack for unpacking a giant suitcase and leaving it the way they found it by the time they’re through. The initial feeling is one of almost sardonic pleasure, but as the soloing becomes more forthright, we find that honesty is indeed the best policy. The proverbial soapbox serves as a stage for Soloff’s biting cynicism, Valente’s political edge, Puschnig’s street smarts, and Sheppard’s down-home wisdom.

“Strange Arrangement” dons the set’s cheekiest title, as the arrangement is rather tame compared to her earlier work. The primary focus here (as throughout), however, is on her fabulous horn section. Whether opening with their bouquet in “All Fall Down” or tooling the binding of “Lo Ultimo,” they add flavor upon flavor without reserve. The latter’s baritone spotlight, courtesy of Pablo Calogero, is one of many elements that make the tune an album standout, even if we must drag our ears a bit to get there. Like the bluesier “Who Will Rescue You?” it slides into home by the skin of its teeth.

Though not as multidimensional as what came before, the feeling is sincere, the compositions solid, and the performances top-notch. This album is also notable for being recorded in Tonstudio Bauer in Ludwigsburg, Germany, where many classic ECM albums were also laid down. The sound is consequently impeccable. Nothing dominates. Given that the influence of Mingus lives large in Bley’s arrangements, we might do best to read this session as a snapshot of a mood expertly crafted for posterity.

Carla Bley
Fleur Carnivore

Lew Soloff, Jens Winther trumpets
Frank Lacy French horn, flugelhorn
Gary Valente trombone
Bob Stewart tuba
Daniel Beaussier oboe, flute
Wolfgang Puschnig, Andy Sheppard, Christof Lauer, Roberto Ottini saxophones
Karen Mantler harmonica, organ, vibes, chimes
Carla Bley piano
Steve Swallow bass
Buddy Williams drums
Don Alias percussion
Recorded live, November 14-16, 1988 at the Montmartre, Copenhagen, Denmark
Remote recording by Sweet Silence Studios
Engineer: Flemming Rasmussen
Assistant: Lau Hansen
Live recording supervision: Michael Mantler
Concert sound: Paul Sparrow
Assistant: John Kenton
Mixed at Grog Kill Studio, Willow, New York
Engineer: Tom Mark
Mastered by Greg Calbi at Sterling Sound, New York
General co-ordination: Michael Mantler
Produced by Carla Bley and Steve Swallow
Release date: October 1, 1989

After the confidential overloads of Night-Glo and subsequent sessions, Carla Bley returns with a 15-piece band in this rich live recording from 1988 made in Copenhagen. The title track, a hat tip to Duke Ellington, is a gradual blush of ornamented sensuality and introduces yet more enduring talents to the Bley nexus in trumpeter Lew Soloff and saxophonists Wolfgang Puschnig and Andy Sheppard. Soloff and Puschnig are handed the first major solos of the set, turning night into day as the band goes from a crawl to a swing. The performance is solid, comfortable, and sumptuous.

Though much of what follows is a retread of what came before, the field in which it is planted is freshly tilled before contact. This includes “Ups And Downs” (reprised from Duets and notable for Frank Lacy’s fluegelhorn in dialogue with the reed of Christof Lauer) and the tripartite “The Girl Who Cried Champagne.” The latter will be familiar to devotees of Sextet and is a worthy showcase for each soloist. There’s even a poetic harmonica solo courtesy of Karen Mantler—the traveler’s daughter, ever traveling herself. All of this thirsts for the final tincture of “Healing Power” (another Sextet holdover). Gospel-tinged and deepened by sermons from trombonist Gary Valente (upward) and Swallow (downward), it’s doctrinal without being pretentious and is a fitting end to an unbreakable set that shows Bley capable of anything, and better than most.

The one standalone classic here is “Song Of The Eternal Waiting Of Canute.” Between its far south-of-the-border vibe, enhanced by bird calls and other natural details, and full moon of brass, the piece cycles back and forth between real-time exposition and jungle fantasy. Thankfully, Bley and her band wield their instruments like machetes, ready to cut through tangle that might get in their way.