
This 2014 Musica Jazz sampler approaches the art of compilation as a meta-statement rather than an inventory, offering four paired selections from albums by the Gary Burton Quartet, Ralph Towner and John Abercrombie, Sam Rivers, and the Miroslav Vitous Group. Keith Jarrett’s “Runes,” from Arbour Zena (ECM 1070), occupies the center as a ritual hinge. Burton opens the first chamber; Towner and Abercrombie narrow the light; Jarrett inhabits the interior court; Rivers fractures the floor plan; Vitous reveals that the exit has been another entrance all along.
“Runes” blooms through a slow orchestral tremolo. Jarrett disturbs the crystalline stillness with narrow shafts of illumination while Charlie Haden’s bass falls in thick droplets, darkening the space it enters. When the piano withdraws, Haden wanders along the edge of perception, testing the boundary between musical presence and psychic afterimage. Jarrett returns from a private expedition carrying neither map nor explanation. His piano peers into the scene, then unfurls immensity behind what had seemed intimate.
The orchestra is drawn elsewhere, leaving the bass to contemplate the consequences of its path. For suspended moments, the voices inhabit incompatible systems of time. Their kinship becomes an article of faith. Jarrett’s improvisations touch familiar solo territories, though the orchestra alters their philosophical weight. Solitude must now negotiate with collective mass and inheritance. The music burrows through successive layers of indecision until Jan Garbarek’s entrance awakens the piece without resolving its dream. The final breath over reed releases the argument into fragile jurisdiction.
Before that central chamber, Gary Burton’s Seven Songs for Quartet and Chamber Orchestra (ECM 1040) establishes a language of lucid instability. In “Three,” Burton and Mick Goodrick exchange chromatic relays whose inevitability never diminishes their surprise. Each phrase knows its destination while concealing that knowledge from the listener. “Nocturne Vulgaire” begins with a groundswell of strings into which Burton lowers his mercurial sound. His mallets revise the ensemble’s gravity, creating buoyancy inside its body. Bows speak through duration; struck metal answers through impact. Their conversation flows into Steve Swallow’s “Arise, Her Eyes,” where precision admits memory and luminous distortion.
The next pair comes from Five Years Later (ECM 1207), Ralph Towner and John Abercrombie’s second duo album after Sargasso Sea. Abercrombie’s rapture rarely announced itself through volume. His sound became mysterious, liberated from the obligation to declare its own intensity. Towner often favored crackling ruptures, yet here their familiar roles drift. The album is a more fragile carnation than its predecessor, bruised by the distance between event and recollection. Its title names the rearrangement time performs upon identity.
In “Late Night Passenger,” Abercrombie builds laddered filaments around Towner’s muted, jangling starlight. The title proposes movement, though the music inhabits transit’s psychological interior, where a reflection hovers in dim glass above an unseen landscape. “Isla” descends further into reverie, with lead and accompaniment treated as temporary offices rather than fixed identities. Hierarchy dissolves without ceremony. Neither musician completes the other, since completion would reduce mystery to possession. Each preserves a clearing in which the other may remain partially unknowable.
Across Jarrett’s axis lies Sam Rivers’s Contrasts (ECM 1162), recorded in 1979 with Dave Holland, while George Lewis and Thurman Barker complete the quartet. Rivers, whose only other ECM appearance came on Holland’s Conference of the Birds, brings his inside-out method to music that escapes the categories prepared for it. “Circles” opens with dense, chewy invention. Thick horns collide with brittle percussion while Lewis’s trombone bubbles through. The title suggests recurrence, yet these circles return carrying damage and knowledge. Rivers makes structure answerable to every new sound. “Solace” gathers itself more gradually from a field of restraint. Its consolation remains unstable, refusing the sentimental demand that comfort arrive in recognizable form. Solace may instead be permission to remain unresolved among others who are equally unfinished.
The compilation concludes with two pieces from the Miroslav Vitous Group’s self-titled album (ECM 1185). Vitous’s sharply individual ensemble avoids collision without collapsing into consensus. “When Face Gets Pale” seizes a strong melodic serpent and follows its muscular curve through tall grass and intermittent sunlight. Vitous’s bass sings with buoyant directness, while Kenny Kirkland’s keyboards gleam with burnished intelligence. John Surman’s baritone saxophone then squeals into existence, tearing the fabric without destroying it. “Sleeping Beauty” moves into a dreamier back room, where Kirkland’s pointillist piano and crisp cymbals exchange upward currents with Vitous’s arco bass and Surman’s soprano. The title carries an old tale’s sediment, though the piece concerns sleep’s obscure labor. Piano notes puncture the dark while bowed bass remembers a language from before speech. Above them, the soprano negotiates the upper air with fragile authority.
These selections form one of the most cohesive Musica Jazz compilations by refusing the sampler’s usual panic of breadth. Each pairing receives enough space to disclose a governing intelligence. Burton’s translucence gives way to the reciprocity of Towner and Abercrombie; Jarrett turns doubt into classical nuance, Rivers bends geometry toward the instant, and Vitous stages plurality without coerced reconciliation.
ECM’s identity emerges as a shared faith in the unfinished encounter rather than a house style imposed from above. Each performance treats sound as a territory where autonomy may approach communion without being absorbed by it. Listening becomes a surrender of jurisdiction, an agreement to let another intelligence alter the proportions of one’s interior life. Perhaps that is the story promised by the title. The music preserves its players, but it also archives the invisible shapes our attention assumes as we move among them. We imagine memory carrying these recordings forward.
